Witness
On a cloudy fall day in New York City I noticed a large red pick-up truck that was parked on my street. The sticker on the rear bumper read: “Special Issue, USA, Permit No. 091101, Terrorist Hunting Permit, No Bag Limit, and Tagging Not Required”. I stared at the truck in disbelief and photographed a few quick frames, feeling anxious that at any moment the owner of the car would show up and catch me in the act. Memories of the xenophobia and discrimination I experienced after 9/11 suddenly inundated me. This moment in October 2004 marked the starting point of my documentary photo project Witness, a collection of black and white photographs taken in New York and California from 2004 to 2009.
America has not been the same since September 11, 2001. The changes that have occurred in my adopted country have been more acute for me because of my identity, being an Iranian-American. The events of September 11th have caused my Iranian identity to eclipse my American one and I have found myself a stranger in my own home. This sense of displacement, coupled with drastic political changes and military conflicts, has made me question the stability of my future here. As a result of this instability I have felt compelled to re-examine America, the country that I have grown to love, the country that I adopted as my second home at the age of twelve. This body of work is a reflection of this examination and an attempt to re-define myself as an Iranian-American.
From 2004 to 2009 I documented the historical transformation that I have been witness to - photographing bumper stickers and subway cards, murals painted on buildings and memorial and protest events. In one photograph a street vendor at the World Trade Center site stands behind framed photographs, key chains and various other trinkets that depict the twin towers, waiting for the tourists passing by to purchase a piece of American tragedy. In another image the words “Don’t Mess with the USA” written by a child on a ceramic tile threatens America’s enemies. These symbols confront us on a daily basis and we mostly ignore them. They have become so deeply ingrained into our environments that most of us do not notice them anymore. Most of these symbols are transitory in nature, fading with each passing day and year. However these symbols do hold some significance as markers of a new era in our history. My photographs capture these fleeting moments of history, marking them as permanent and fixed icons.
As I left New York and moved to Southern California in 2006 I questioned how I was going to continue this documentary project. Surely September 11th had a profound effect on the country as a whole but how did this manifest in the carefree culture of Los Angeles and the surrounding suburbs? This question was quickly answered as I drove past a neighbor’s house. On the garage door, marked with blue masking tape, were written: Beloved Sons Lost in War, 2411. Again I photographed a few quick frames but this time I did not feel anxious as I did two years earlier. A feeling of grief took over me, followed by an urgency to continue documenting. As I began to discover my new surroundings I discovered that the aftermath of September 11 had largely touched upon Southern California’s military community. I continued working on this project until early 2009, when I decided to take a break and edit the body of photographs from the past five years of work.
My intention from the start of this project was to capture a slice of the historical time I was witness to and present it to the public. As I continued photographing for 5 years I also realized that these images were my way of resolving my identity in a post September 11th America. These images are captured on film and printed on gelatin silver paper, separated by the 2 different locations I’ve photographed – New York and California. This division is also reflective of my dual identity. I believe that my dual identity has created a unique perspective for viewers here and has shown the transformation America has gone through in this past several years.
Special Issue, Brooklyn, NY, 2004
Don't Mess, New York City, NY, 2004
Subway Card, Brooklyn, NY, 2004
No More Lives, Brooklyn, NY, 2004
Site of the World Trade Center, New York City, NY, 2005
Family, New York City, NY, 2005
Vendor, New York City, NY, 2005
Nothing Accomplished, Brooklyn, NY, 2005
Conserving for Tomorrow, New York City, NY, 2005
Forever Brave, New York City, NY, 2005
Building 7, New York City, NY, 2005
Cemetery, New York City, NY, 2005
Doorway, Brooklyn, NY, 2005
Mural in Red Hook, Brooklyn, NY, 2005
Patriot, New York City, NY, 2005
Liberty with Bush, New York City, NY, 2005
Mural in Lower East Side, New York City, NY, 2007
Sam, New York City, NY, 2006
This Phone is Tapped, Brooklyn, NY, 2006
Allah is Our Protector, Brooklyn, NY, 2006
Photo at Brooklyn Promenade, Brooklyn, NY, 2007
We Will Not, New York City, NY, 2007
Poster in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY, 2007
Tourists at the World Trade Center, New York City, NY, 2007
Young Veteran, New York City, NY, 2007
Now Renting, Costa Mesa, CA, 2006
Beloved Sons Lost in War, Fountain Valley, CA, 2006
Never Forget, Newport Beach, CA, 2007
It's God's Job, Newport Beach, CA, 2007
Bush Orwell, Fountain Valley, CA, 2007
War is Not Healthy, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Repent, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Stop Bush, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
My Son, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Cardboard Coffins, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
3067, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Life is God, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Bring Them Home, Los Angeles, CA, 2007
Memorial, Irvine, CA, 2007
United We Stand, Santa Ana, CA, 2008
Memorial at the Library, Fountain Valley, CA, 2008
Memorial at Fire Station 88, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Memorial at LAFD Training Center, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Memorial at LAFD Training Center, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Memorial at LAFD Training Center, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Memorial at LAFD Training Center, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Memorial at Santa Monica Beach, Los Angeles, CA, 2008
Bite of Broadway, Santa Ana, CA, 2008
American Spirit, Tustin, CA, 2009
Ha Ha, Los Angeles, CA, 2009